10 Effective Interview Questions for Recruiter Hiring

The guiding principle for any skilled recruiter emphasizes the utmost importance of people, recognizing that the foundation for creating a sustainable organization lies in consistently attracting top-tier talent.

It's logical that recruitment leaders hold a profound concern for the individuals they select to join their talent acquisition team. Now, the question arises: How can you ascertain whether someone possesses the qualities of a top-notch recruiter? 

In order to assist you in this assessment, Recruitery has compiled a comprehensive list of 10 effective interview questions when hiring recruiters.

hiring recruiters

What is the role of a recruiter?

Let's start with the fundamentals: A recruiter is employed by a company to connect skilled candidates with available job opportunities. They actively scout and contact candidates through platforms like Handshake and act as the intermediary between the candidate and the company throughout the interview process.

What skills and qualities make a great recruiter?

In this section, we will discover the skills and quality needed to excel at the role recruiter 


Recruiters often attract extroverts because their role involves extensive networking and interacting with many people. Confidence is essential, not only in the recruiter's self-assurance but also in the skills they offer to clients and candidates.

Good Communication Skills

Effective communication is vital in recruitment. Recruiters need to excel in face-to-face, phone, and email communication. Keeping clients and candidates informed and acting as a bridge between them is crucial.

hiring recruiters

Approachable Demeanor

Building positive professional relationships with clients and candidates is essential. Being likable and personable is important to create trust and facilitate future business opportunities through recommendations and collaboration.

Good Listener

Recruiters should balance talking and listening. Understanding the needs and requirements of clients and candidates is crucial for successful placements.

Strong Sales Skills

Recruitment is essentially a sales role. Recruiters sell their services to clients and job opportunities to candidates. Without sales skills, it's challenging to attract clients and generate business.


Recruitment is highly competitive, and recruiters often work on commission or bonus structures. Being driven and performing under pressure is crucial to meet targets and maximize earning potential.

Good at Multitasking

Recruiters handle multiple jobs from different clients simultaneously. Effective time management and the ability to prioritize tasks are vital to manage the workload efficiently.


Recruiters must remain patient when things don't go as planned, such as rescheduled interviews or unsuccessful initial searches. Maintaining professionalism and composure in such situations is important.

10 Interview questions that hiring managers can pose when recruiting recruiters.

In this section, we provide you 10 questions to evaluate the quality of candidates applying for the  recruiter position. If you’re applying for this job, you can also use these examples of questions to prepare for your interview

  1. How would you characterize your relationship with your previous hiring manager?

Recruiter success hinges on building strong relationships with hiring managers and collaborating effectively. During candidate interviews, assess their experience with past hiring managers to gauge their approach to relationship management. Look for candidates who prioritize equal partnership rather than those who passively follow manager directives.

Sample answer: I maintain contact with my last hiring managers, emphasizing two-way relationships. Our mutual goal is to find the ideal candidate, and we collaborate closely in achieving that objective.

hiring recruiters

  1. Share your approach to candidates who do not secure a job.

Recruiters are often driven by the quantity and speed of successful hires, which can lead to neglecting rejected candidates' experience. This approach harms the company's reputation. Top recruiters prioritize providing a positive experience to all candidates, focusing on clear and consistent communication throughout the process to avoid leaving anyone in uncertainty.

Sample answer: I personally call candidates who aren't selected for a job, sharing client feedback and highlighting areas for improvement in future interviews. Keeping candidates informed and updated throughout the process is a priority for me.

  1. Can you recount the last two instances where you used data for recruiting?

Data is increasingly important in recruiting, enabling strategic partnerships with hiring managers and effective talent pool targeting. Candidates should demonstrate their data-driven recruitment practices to prove their proficiency.

Sample answer: I leveraged data from LinkedIn Talent Insights to identify specific skills in high demand within the market, which helped us fine-tune our job postings and target the right candidates more effectively. In another case, I used applicant tracking system data to analyze our recruitment funnel, identifying bottlenecks and areas for improvement, resulting in a 20% reduction in time-to-hire.

  1. Describe a situation where you hired an unsuitable candidate, what you learned, and how you applied those lessons.

Recruitment inevitably involves some unsuccessful hires, which can be costly. When candidates acknowledge past recruitment mistakes, it reveals their ability to learn and adapt. Their responses provide insights into their capacity for growth and improvement from past failures.

Sample answer: I once hired a candidate who, despite impressive qualifications, didn't integrate well into our team and struggled with the day-to-day responsibilities. This experience taught me the importance of assessing not only skills and experience but also cultural fit and soft skills. I implemented more comprehensive interview techniques to evaluate interpersonal qualities and team dynamics, resulting improved team cohesion.

  1. How do you measure the quality of hire in your recruiting efforts?

The quality of hire is a complex topic with no universal answer, even for experts. While defining and assessing it remains challenging, it's widely recognized as the most crucial recruitment metric. A strong recruitment candidate should have a perspective or theory on measuring it.

Sample answer: I measure the quality of hire through a combination of metrics, including on-the-job performance, retention rates, and feedback from hiring managers and team members. These indicators help me gauge whether a candidate not only met the technical qualifications but also integrated well into the team and contributed to our company culture. 

  1. Share an experience when a top candidate declined a job offer and what insights you gained.

Recruiters often encounter candidates who decline offers. Top recruiters focus on understanding the reasons behind the decline and improving their approach for future opportunities. This insight helps them handle offer stages more strategically.

Sample answer: I had a top candidate decline an offer due to work-life balance concerns. This highlighted the importance of addressing these expectations early in the interview process. I now ensure thorough discussions about work-life balance to avoid such issues.

  1. What is your new-hire retention rate?

Recruiters often feel pressure to fill positions quickly, but quality should never be compromised. Look for a recruiter who prioritizes long-term candidate commitment, even in time-sensitive situations. Low turnover can indicate effective vetting and clear job expectations.

Sample answer: Our new-hire retention rate stands at 92%. We prioritize candidate fit and clear expectations to ensure candidates are committed to long-term roles, which has contributed to this positive retention figure.

  1. How would you position our company to potential candidates?

Assess the recruiter's ability to stand out and attract top candidates in a competitive market, gauging their creativity, critical thinking, and prior research on your company.

Sample answer: I would position your company as a dynamic and innovative workplace that values individual growth and contributions. I'd highlight the supportive culture, opportunities for skill development, and the chance to work with a team of passionate professionals. Additionally, emphasizing the company's commitment to diversity, sustainability, and making a positive impact on society can attract candidates who share these values.

  1. How do you stay informed about the latest trends in the recruitment industry?

Recruitment is dynamic, requiring adaptability to new methods. Exceptional recruiters stay informed about their industry, regardless of specific sources. To assess their industry awareness and innovative perspectives, ask about recent developments that interest them.

Sample answer: I stay informed by regularly reading industry publications, following influential blogs, and participating in webinars. I also make it a point to network with other professionals in the field to exchange insights and discuss emerging trends. This keeps me up to date with the latest happenings in the recruitment industry and helps me stay innovative in my approach.

hiring recruiters

  1. What aspect of being a recruiter do you find most fulfilling? 

Recruiters who are genuinely passionate about their work can inspire candidates and create excitement about job opportunities. Pay attention to responses that reveal what motivates them, whether it's connecting with candidates, helping individuals find the right roles, or enjoying candidate stories. 

Sample answer: The most fulfilling aspect of my job is enabling individuals to thrive in their roles. I genuinely enjoy engaging with candidates and hearing their unique stories. Recruiting gives me a sense of personal fulfillment while contributing to the overall economy.


In conclusion, just as the right tools are essential for any task, selecting a recruiter who meets all the criteria is crucial to attract exceptional candidates. When hiring a recruiter, seek someone who demonstrates genuine enthusiasm for your company and a sincere concern for each candidate they encounter. Recruitery hopes you have discovered insightful information as well as will be able to use 10 effective interview questions when hiring recruiters in your hiring process after reading this article.